Throat Strikes For Self-Defense Civilian Vs Military From Legal Point of View
Throat Strikes, the legal aspect of different strikes.
After eye strikes and groin strikes, the throat strikes are probably the biggest go-to technique in self-defense community.
Most traditional martial arts styles teach some form of these techniques.
Today two variations are discussed. The “Y” strike or the “web” strike and the thumb strike.
While both strikes seem simple to execute, I recommend using caution. The webs strike requires strong, stabilized wrist and conditioned fingers and thumbs. While the thumb strike requires conditioned thumb. If the hand is positioned wrong and the contact is made with thumb or fingers at the wrong angle, injuries are very possible. This, of course, will put the defender in a very bad position.
This article speaks the practitioners who have taken the appropriate steps to train for the strikes. Meaning the hands, wrist, and fingers were well conditioned. Strikes have been practiced for automation and accuracy.
In self-defense community, there are two rather conflicting schools of thoughts.
School One: Do as much damage as you need to survive. It’s better to be judged by 12 than carried by 6.
School Two: Don’t practice the techniques you would not want to use. If you practice something that can do serious damage, you will probably use it. If you use it, you may face hefty criminal or civil penalties.
The choice of technique argument has always existed. During my own training, I have seen people talk about the amount of reasonable force frequently. For example in blade community, a common question focuses on questions like these; If there is only one chance to do a surprise slash. Should it be to the shoulder or the throat? Shoulder won’t take life, but may not be enough to stop the attacker. Deepthroat slash will be enough to stop the attacker, but may become a legal nightmare.
The same argument often applied to weaponless combat and techniques, such as knee attacks. A sidekick or oblique kick to the knee, at the right angle and at the right force can break the knee. While a roundhouse to the thigh will not break the leg, but may not be enough to stop the attack.
Of course, all these questions come from an assumption. The assumption is that all the techniques are mastered at such a high level, that when deployed, they will do the damage they intend to do.
So the Civilian/Military classification comes from the potential repercussions perspective. Civilians are not expected to kill in combat, and military personnel are. Out of the two, the civilians are expected to exercise restraint and often are praised for it.
Ok, back to throat strikes. If two strikes are compared on the target and point of impact, we can easily see why one will do so much more damage than the other. (Providing that the same amount of force is used)
Web Strike or “Y” Throat Strike
The web strike usually is aimed and lands on the Thyroid Cartilage. Adam’s apple is the protrusion of this structure. It protects from impact. It won’t protect from severe impacts, such as a strong sidekick, but it offers some protection. At the same time, the force of the “Y” strike is distributed, through a surface area between thumb and index finger. A combination of hard cartilage protection and force distribution, offer an ability to withstand a mild to moderate impact.
Thumb Throat Strike
A thumb strike’s impact is aimed at the tracheal cartilages. This is a rather weak collection of soft tissue. The point of impact is less than the size of a penny. If a thumb throat strike is made at the same force as the web strike, the impact is at least 5-6 times stronger due to a smaller area. It is also at least 3 times stronger due to weaker protection factor. This means 15x the force.
The common counter-argument for the danger of thumb strikes is combatant control of force. This means, when you strike at the weak part of the throat, you simply don’t hit hard. However, it this realistic? When someone is trying to hurt you, and you have a shot at his throat… Do you hold back? Can you control yourself when in danger and under adrenaline? What if the other person moves his body toward you? The force of impact will be much stronger now and beyond your control.
The Court looks at the damage done, not technique.
The judge won’t base his ruling solely on what the attacker was hit with. What he will look at closely is amount damage done. I know a case when a martial artist killed another person with a punch to the head. He went to jail. Would he have gotten the same sentence if the punch only dropped the other guy? Probably not.
Don’t rely on “self-defense” situation or “I was only trying to defend myself”
The issue that often comes up is, what is a “self-defense” situation?
Is an altercation in a bar or a mall a “self-defense” situation?
Is a kid bullied in school or in the neighborhood a “self-defense” situation?
Judges usually expect people to walk away or call authorities.
“He got in my face and I had to defend myself is a “self-defense” situation to you, but may not be so to someone else.
Just because the force you used is completely justified to you, does not mean it is to someone else. There are countless cases of kids getting feed up and hurting a bully, who tormented them. If the result was severe damage or death, they were held responsible almost every time.
Know the laws, be aware, be safe!